Friday, March 21, 2025

Meanderings on Diverse Merit, Equitable Merit, and Inclusive Merit

 



  

We condemn racism, ethnocentrism, tribalism, and any ideology or social practice based on false and misleading beliefs or ideologies that one group of human beings is superior to all other groups of human beings.

From the 2024 Social Principles of the United Methodist Church, Social Community-Other Social Issues-L

  Having been born and lived my youngest most formative years in an exclusively white county in Tennessee during the late 1950s and early 1960s, and having been born into a family that believed that “white” was the only authentic people in society, my first perception of non-white people was that they “are not quite the fullness of white people”.

   And then, at some point while I was in grade school (or elementary school as I was soon to learn) my family moved to Detroit looking for work.

   The school I attended in Detroit in 1964 was A.L. Holmes which had a large population of black kids, Puerto Rican kids, and South American kids. At this school I was introduced to new and interesting ways to think about music, poetry, and world-view. Silly as it may seem, my transformative moment occurred when I was standing in line for lunch. Black kids in front of me, black kids behind me, and I felt awkward. I did not know how to relate to anyone but a white person. And then, from down the hallway, I heard a gathering of black girls talking and one said “Hey, let’s go talk to that cute white boy.” At that moment my mind had changed and my heart was open to allowing these girls into my friendship construct.

   At some point I transferred from A.L. Holmes to Carstens Elementary.

It was at Carstens that I found new friends, one from Egypt, one from Saudi Arabia. I learned about Islam. My Egyptian friend next door taught me the meaning of the phrase “people of the Book”, meaning Quran. I learned that Jews and Jesus followers are people of the Book. We have a favorable place in their faith.

    By the time I had moved from Detroit to Elkhart County Indiana in 1969, I had accepted that many races, nationalities, and religions gave life much more meaning and fulfillment than just being around Baptist white people all of the time.

    I had also learned that I, as a white person, experienced much more ease of social mobility than did nonwhite people. While in Detroit, it seemed that the white teachers, intentionally or not, showed favor to me over black kids regarding just about any opportunity including serving on Student Council. This type of favor tends to instill within a person a sense of preference or superiority. But, having developed friendships with black kids, I learned that they were very smart, talented, and capable. I learned early that many people are left out of opportunities and “social place” merely because of their race.

    Regardless of the contemporary push against the Diversity, Equity, Inclusion movement, I assert that America, and every State or Territory of the United States, will benefit from proactively providing opportunities for nonwhite people to have opportunities in employment and education.

    I encourage intentional efforts to reach beyond the most prevalent demographic (white people) in employment and education, to give nonwhite people equal opportunity. Perhaps Human Resource departments can devise methods of providing to the interviewer/hiring agent only job-relevant information which does not include name and address. Perhaps identify the applicant as Candidate 10 AM, Candidate 3PM, or some other blind nomenclature. Often, name and address can inadvertently allow the interviewer a prejudiced pre-opinion even before meeting the applicant. The applicant, regardless of race, age, gender, nationality, or religion, should have equal opportunity to apply.

    Notably, in all of the current movement against DEI initiatives, it is worth pointing out that the Congressionally passed Equal Opportunity Act is still in effect. You may visit the official eeoc.gov website to see that such laws still pertain. Particularly informative is the eeoc site https://www.eeoc.gov/employees-job-applicants  which explicitly states the protected classes.

   I acknowledge that many white people have felt discriminated against.

   I have not escaped negative discrimination in my life. As a student in school, elementary, Junior and senior high, I was the last person chosen for a sports team. Any time I tried out for a sport I did not make the cut. This was because, compared to other students trying out, I was short, frail, non-muscular. And so, the team was fixed before I had a chance to prove myself. But, what I lacked in the previously identified attributes, I more than compensated with my agility, responsiveness, and quickness. Yet, how was a coach to discover those attributes without looking beyond my appearance and giving me a chance to prove myself in action.

   I remember a time when, in high school, during Physical Education class I committed myself to exceeding my previous number of pull-ups each day. One day, while the teacher was watching and counting, he replied “If this had been a sanctioned competition, you would have broken a school record”. One would never have guessed by looking at my arm muscles. But I had previously learned the trick of cadence, breath, and focus to achieve the objective.

   Records can be broken if we take the initiative to look beyond appearance, race, religion, nationality, language, gender and all other personal attributes that are not relevant to the job or task.

    To borrow and repurpose a phrase from Thomas Payne: We have it within our power to remake America. Let’s prove our exceptionality by making real the idea of “all men are created equal”.